Rating: 3.5/5
…
Hooks hold fast, melodies are memorable, and Nightwish is learning how to transform into this new band they aspire to be. A gradual metamorphosis for sure, this feels like an awkward phase that would have benefitted from editing.

Rating: 2/5 …

It still seems unclear if the woman wants to keep recording with session musicians, rejoin Nightwish, or pursue a career outside of heavy music. Frankly, of the three, I hope for the latter. Tarja has a beautiful voice, but if she continues this path without a talented band in and of themselves, her releases will grow increasingly bloated with filler.

  Nightwish – “Made In Hong Kong (And Various Other Places)” released March 24, 2009 on Roadrunner On their first live album with vocalist Annette Olzon, the band wisely decide to trim the fat off Dark Passion Play for the included setlist (though the heaviest track, “Master Passion Greed,” is missed). It starts with three of their sharpest hooks (arranged by strength, in descending order), followed by a brilliant execution of their epic 14 min album opener, and in case that doesn’t grab ya, the sweeping “Sahara” soon will. Then their more daring aspects take shape with the acoustic [...read more]